Share
Facebook 
Twitter 
LinkedIn 
Pinterest 
Email 
The ASPCA (American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals) is one of the most recognized animal welfare organizations in the United States. It is known for its emotionally impactful advertisements and strong reputation for aiding needy animals. But is the ASPCA truly a good charity?
In this post, we’ll examine the ASPCA’s work, resources, and comparison to other animal organizations. We’ll also review independent ratings, explore some controversies, and give you practical tips for choosing the best animal charity for your donations.
Jump to Section [Hide]
What is the ASPCA?
The ASPCA stands for the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. It works to protect animals from harm and improve their well-being.
History and background
The ASPCA was founded in 1866 and became America’s first animal welfare group. Henry Bergh founded it to stop animal cruelty.
It received its IRS ruling in 1921 and is a nonprofit organization. Its EIN is 13-1623829, helping track tax forms like IRS Form 990 for accountability.
Core mission and values
ASPCA’s mission is to stop animal cruelty in the U.S. It focuses on saving animals from abuse, neglect, and harm.
Their values center around compassion and respect for all living creatures. They aim to protect shelter dogs, cats, and other animals through rescue efforts and care services. By donating, you can also support their fight against factory farming practices.
Helping animals find safe homes is at their heart, too.
Key services and areas of focus
The ASPCA focuses on animal rescue, adoption, and care. It runs one adoption center that helps pets find new homes. The organization also works to stop cruelty in areas like puppy mills, factory farms, and slaughterhouses.
You’ll also see them involved in disaster response. Their teams help animals during emergencies like hurricanes or floods. Education is another focus. Through outreach programs, they teach communities about pet care and stop abuse.
ASPCA’s Programs and Initiatives
The ASPCA offers various programs to help animals and pet owners. These efforts aim to make a lasting difference in animal care and protection.
Animal rescue and adoption services
ASPCA helps rescue animals in need, giving them better lives. In 2021, it found homes for 1,400 pets. Many rescued animals receive proper veterinary care before adoption.
Around 40% of its budget goes to shelter services and grants for other animal groups. This support aids no-kill shelters and fosters pet adoptions. Your donation can help save more abused or homeless pets.
Advocacy and legal efforts
The organization fights against animal suffering through strong legal efforts. It has opposed horse-drawn carriages in New York City, spending hundreds of thousands on lobbying. In 2023, it built a federal lobbying coalition with abolitionist vegan groups.
It also works to change laws that protect animals and hold abusers accountable. Legal actions often target cases of cruelty or neglect under racketeer-influenced corrupt organizations like the RICO Act.
By shaping policies, the group seeks better treatment for animals nationwide.
Community outreach and education
The ASPCA focuses on teaching kindness to animals. It often visits schools and communities to spread animal care and welfare awareness. These programs help people learn how to prevent animal abuse and neglect.
They also work with local groups like veterinarians and rescue teams. Workshops teach people how to spot cruelty or assist in animal emergencies. This helps build stronger, informed neighborhoods that value humane societies.
Disaster response and emergency relief
Disasters can leave animals in danger. You may think of storms, floods, or wildfires. In these moments, a rescue group steps in to save lives. They help by providing shelter, food, and medical care for affected animals.
Efforts include transporting stranded pets to safe areas and reuniting them with their families. Mobile clinics often give quick treatment on-site during emergencies. Teams also work with local animal shelters to handle the overflow of rescued pets.
Financial Transparency and Accountability
Donors deserve to know how charities manage their money. Precise spending details can build trust.
How donations are allocated
The ASPCA uses its funds in specific ways. A large share, 75.41%, goes directly to programs helping animals. These include rescue efforts, adoption services, education, and advocacy work.
Only 2% of the budget supports U.S. pet shelters. Part of your donation also covers administrative costs and fundraising campaigns. While most resources aid animals, some critics argue that more should help local shelters directly.
Percentage spent on programs vs. administration
According to CharityWatch’s Spring 2023 guide, the ASPCA spends 49% of its funds on overhead, including costs for administration and fundraising. Some donors may find this percentage high compared to other charities.
In 2017, ASPCA made $248 million in revenue and spent $221 million. A significant portion went to programs, but nearly half was used for operating costs. If keeping most of your donation for direct services matters to you, consider reviewing similar non-profits like the Humane Society or local SPCAs.
Fundraising tips and costs
Since 2008, they have spent $421 million on fundraising. For every dollar raised, about 19 cents go to cover fundraising costs. This is their Fundraising Efficiency Ratio.
Mail campaigns, TV ads, and online efforts attract donors. These methods cost money but help reach many people. Some worry that these expenses take away from helping animals directly.
Executive compensation
Matt Bershadker, the CEO of the ASPCA, earned $1,085,129 in 2021. This is a very high salary for a leader of a nonprofit organization. Many other top ASPCA employees also earn six-figure salaries.
Over 259 workers make more than $100,000 each year.
Supporters say competitive pay attracts skilled leaders to run large nonprofits like this one. Critics argue that such big salaries take away from helping animals directly. It’s important to check if you feel their spending aligns with your values before donating.
Independent Charity Ratings and Reviews
Check how experts rate ASPCA’s work and see what these reviews reveal about its impact and efficiency.
Charity Navigator and Guidestar ratings
Charity Navigator gives the ASPCA a 99% score, the highest rating, and Four-Star Charity status. The Accountability & Finance category scores a perfect 100%, which means the charity is transparent and uses funds responsibly.
Guidestar also rates the ASPCA highly. They receive a Platinum Seal of Transparency, which shows strong governance and accountability. These ratings highlight their trustworthiness among non-profit organizations.
Summary of third-party evaluations
In Spring 2023, CharityWatch rated the ASPCA a C-minus. This rating reflects concerns about its financial decisions and how it uses donations.
Reports show only 2% of the ASPCA’s budget goes to U.S. pet shelters. Third-party reviews often criticize this low allocation, and some donors question whether their money significantly impacts animals in need.
Donor feedback and testimonials
Many donors feel their money helps more at local shelters than with big groups like the ASPCA. Some, like Texasrho83 and Bob, share worries about where the funds go. Only 7% of donations help local animal groups through grants.
People often ask why leadership gets such large paychecks. CEO Matthew Bershadker earns a significant salary, raising questions about spending choices. These concerns make some rethink supporting this nonprofit organization over smaller charities.
Controversies and Criticisms
The ASPCA has faced questions about using donor funds, raising concerns over spending priorities. Critics have also pointed to transparency issues in its financial reports and practices.
Notable investigations
In 1994, the ASPCA had a high kill rate. Over 50% of animals brought in were euthanized. Out of 60,000 animals, about 35,000 were put down. This raised concerns about how they handled animal care.
In 2019, an incident during transport led to the death of 20 dogs. Details from that investigation have not been shared with the public. These events caused some people to question their transparency and efficiency in handling such cases.
Legal issues and settlements
The ASPCA faced a major legal issue in 2012. It settled a federal RICO Act lawsuit for $9.3 million. This case came after accusations of improper tactics in lawsuits against Ringling Bros.
Circus.
In another incident, the ASPCA euthanized over 100 animals in 2011. One case was Oreo, a dog that sparked public outrage. These events raised concerns about its practices and decisions regarding animal welfare.
Transparency and efficiency concerns
ASPCA’s financial practices raise concerns. CharityWatch reported in its Spring 2023 guide that 49% of funds go to overhead costs, like salaries and fundraising. This means less than half of their donations support direct programs for animals.
Their assets grew from $62 million in 2000 to over $340 million by 2019. Despite this growth, some critics question how well they manage donations. Donors and charity watchdogs have also criticized high executive pay.
Always review IRS forms 990 or other audit details before donating to any nonprofit organizations like ASPCA.org.
Responses from the ASPCA
The ASPCA has defended itself against claims about spending and transparency. It often states that most donations go toward animal welfare programs, such as rescues and adoptions. Public statements stress their commitment to saving animals and helping communities.
It also acknowledges ongoing efforts to improve efficiency. In past legal matters, like settlements or investigations, the group typically highlights changes to address concerns about record-keeping or policies.
The Impact of the ASPCA’s Work
The ASPCA has saved countless animals, changed policies, and brought hope to communities.
Noteworthy achievements and success stories
In 2021, the ASPCA found homes for 1,400 pets, helping many animals leave shelters and join loving families. Their efforts focus on saving stray or abandoned animals.
With a Program Expense Ratio of 75.41%, most funds support their mission. They use donations wisely to rescue and protect thousands of animals each year. These acts show their dedication to animal welfare.
Animal lives saved and community impact
The ASPCA saves thousands of animals every year through rescue programs. It assists pets in unsafe or abusive situations and supports pet adoptions to give animals loving homes.
Their efforts touch local communities, too. Education programs teach people about caring for animals and preventing cruelty. Even with a large budget, only 2% reportedly goes to U.S. shelters, raising questions about the broader impact on stray pets nationwide.
Critiques about effectiveness and efficiency
The ASPCA has been criticized for spending nearly half of its funds on overhead. CharityWatch gave it a C-minus in Spring 2023, noting that only 51% goes to programs directly helping animals.
Critics argue this raises concerns about efficiency and priorities.
Its assets grew from $62 million in 2000 to over $340 million by 2019. Some say the growth shows success, while others question why more isn’t spent on animal care. High fundraising costs have also drawn negative attention.
ASPCA vs. Other Animal Charities
You might wonder how the ASPCA compares to similar groups. Comparing their strengths and weaknesses can help you decide which cause to support.
Comparison with the Humane Society
The Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) focuses on broader issues, like factory farming and wildlife protection. ASPCA centers more on rescuing pets, providing adoption services, and local animal welfare.
Both work to stop cruelty but use different methods.
HSUS spends much of its budget on campaigns and big-picture changes, while the ASPCA directs more funds toward hands-on programs, such as shelter assistance. Both organizations face criticism for transparency or effectiveness in some areas.
Research each group’s priorities before donating.
Comparison with SPCA International
SPCA International focuses on global animal welfare. The ASPCA works mainly in the United States and often helps rescue animals in war zones or disaster areas worldwide.
The ASPCA provides adoption services, legal advocacy, and U.S.-based rescue missions.
SPCA International has fewer programs than the ASPCA but aims for a broader global reach. It is smaller and spends less on administration costs than the ASPCA’s larger structure, which has higher expenses.
Both charities face criticism about transparency and efficiency, yet they target different needs in animal care.
Comparison with local shelters
Local shelters usually focus on their nearby communities, working to rescue and rehome stray or abandoned animals in their area. On the other hand, the ASPCA operates nationally and only runs one adoption center.
It is not connected to local SPCAs, although they share similar names.
Your donations to a small shelter might go mostly toward animal care, as these groups often have tight budgets. However, the ASPCA also spends money on larger projects like advocacy, legal efforts, and disaster response.
This difference makes local shelters more hands-on for direct animal help, while the ASPCA works at a wider level across states.
Strengths and weaknesses
The ASPCA runs many programs that help animals. It rescues pets, provides adoption services, and offers emergency relief after disasters. Its advocacy efforts also push for better animal welfare laws.
These actions show its commitment to saving lives.
Critics raise concerns about high costs. The CEO’s pay was over $1 million in 2021, which some find excessive. Since 2008, the group has spent $421 million on fundraising alone. Some feel this money could go directly to helping more animals instead of admin expenses or ads.
How to Choose the Right Animal Charity
Learn how to pick charities that align with your values and use donations wisely.
Steps for evaluating any charity’s credibility
Check the charity’s rating on platforms like Charity Navigator or Guidestar. Look for high scores in transparency and accountability. Confirm their nonprofit status, such as a 501(c)(3) designation, to ensure tax-deductible donations.
Review their Form 990 for details about finances and management. See how much money goes to programs compared to administrative costs. Avoid charities criticized for high overhead expenses or poor budget use.
Evaluate if they meet their mission effectively based on reports and public feedback.
Key questions to ask before donating
Ask how donations are used. Check if the charity shares financial reports and shows spending details. Look for the percentage of funds spent on programs versus overhead costs like executive compensation.
Find out if it has a strong Charity Navigator or Guidestar rating. Also, look for any history of scandals, embezzlement, or legal issues, like those tied to some charities under scrutiny.
Ask about their core mission and recent achievements to ensure your values align with theirs.
Understanding financial reports and program outcomes
Check how donations are used. The ASPCA earns over $400 million yearly, mostly from fundraising. About 49% goes to overhead costs, higher than other charities. Only $5.8 million helped local shelters in 2021.
Charity Navigator rates the ASPCA highly for accountability and financial management at 99%. Yet, CharityWatch gives it a C-minus due to its spending choices. Understanding these numbers can help you decide if it aligns with your giving goals.
Resources for independent charity research
Look into tools like Charity Navigator and CharityWatch. They rate charities, including the ASPCA, based on finances and effectiveness. Charity Navigator gave the ASPCA a Four-Star rating, but CharityWatch rated it C-minus due to high overhead.
Check public financial reports, too. These can show how donations are used. The ASPCA has around $500 million in assets, worth reviewing before donating. Always ask about their employer identification number for transparency.
Final Thoughts: Is the ASPCA a Good Charity?
The ASPCA has done significant work for animals, but faces questions about spending and efficiency. Think carefully before deciding if it’s the best charity for your support.
Weighing the pros and cons
The ASPCA has strengths but also faces challenges. It holds a Four-Star Charity status with a 99% rating from Charity Navigator, which shows high accountability. Its programs include animal rescue, advocacy, and disaster response.
They raised over $400 million yearly, yet only 2% supports U.S. pet shelters.
Critics point to high overhead costs and executive compensation. Some accuse them of euthanizing animals despite promoting “no kill” ideas. They’ve faced legal issues like lawsuits under racketeer-influenced charges and concerns about transparency in their impact reports.
Supporting ASPCA helps many animals, but comes with questions about spending efficiency.
Who might benefit from supporting the ASPCA
Animal lovers who care about stopping cruelty can benefit from supporting this group. Families looking to adopt pets will find help through their rescue and adoption services.
If you value strong animal protection laws, your support helps fund legal efforts and advocacy. Donations also help communities needing education on pet care or disaster relief.
Alternatives for animal welfare donors
Local animal shelters often need help more than large charities like the ASPCA. Donations to these shelters directly support animals in your community. Many struggle with limited funds and resources, so even small contributions can make a big impact.
Volunteering at local shelters is another excellent option. You can offer to walk dogs, clean cages, or assist with adoptions. This provides hands-on help that large national groups may not deliver directly to animals near you.
Additional reading:
