Buying a car is a big decision. You might wonder, “Is buying a new or used car better?” Both choices have pros and cons, making the decision tricky. Many individuals struggle to find the right balance between their budget and what they need from a vehicle.
Did you know new cars lose about 20% of their value in just one year? Used cars, on the other hand, hold their value longer but can come with unknown problems. Deciding between these options depends on your money, needs, and priorities.
This post will help clear up your doubts. You’ll learn everything—costs, maintenance needs, insurance tips, and more! Keep reading… you’ll find the answers you need!
Jump to Section [Hide]
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing Between a New or Used Car
Your choice depends on more than just price—it’s about balancing costs and needs. Consider how each option can impact your wallet now and in the future!
1. Budget and Affordability
New cars cost more upfront. The average loan amount for a new car is $40,184, with monthly payments around $726. Used cars are cheaper, averaging $27,167 in loans and $533 monthly.
Fewer cars under $25,000 exist now—these sales dropped 78% over five years. Auto loan rates have improved since the Federal Reserve cut interest rates in 2024. Lower rates can help reduce costs on both new and used vehicles.
2. Depreciation and Resale Value
Cars lose value quickly after purchase. A new car drops 20% of its value in the first year and 60% within five years. Buying a one-year-old vehicle costs about 80% of its original price—saving you money upfront.
Used cars hold their value better over time, especially after 100,000 miles. Depreciation slows down at that point. Tools like Kelley Blue Book help check resale prices for new and used models.
This can guide your decision to make a smarter investment long-term.
3. Maintenance and Repair Costs
Used cars often come with higher repair costs as they age. Parts may wear out, and warranties might no longer cover the expenses. You’ll need to budget for unexpected repairs, especially if the car is over five years old.
New cars cost less to maintain in their early years. Most come with warranties covering up to three years or 36,000 miles—saving you money on major fixes. These vehicles also face fewer mechanical issues at the start.
4. Insurance Costs and Coverage
Car insurance costs are higher for new cars. A brand-new vehicle may need full coverage, leading to bigger premiums. On average, insurance premiums for a five-year-old car are 27% lower than those of a new model.
Older used cars often qualify for reduced coverage options. This can save you money over time. Vehicles priced over $60,000 see even steeper increases in premium rates due to higher repair and replacement costs.
Make sure to compare quotes before deciding what fits your budget best!
5. Financing and Loan Considerations
Interest rates for loans vary between new and used cars. New car loans typically have lower rates, averaging 7.03%. Used car loans often come with higher rates, around 11.35%. Lenders like PenFed offer competitive options, starting at 4.44% APR for terms up to 84 months with no early payoff fees.
Used vehicles might seem cheaper upfront, but consider monthly payments and interest over time. Companies like CarMax allow flexible financing, starting at a $500 down payment and repaying it over 36 to 72 months.
Keep your credit score in mind—it affects loan approval and interest costs significantly.
Benefits of Buying a New Car
A new car offers peace of mind with fewer worries about repairs. It also brings modern features that make driving safer and more enjoyable.
1. Full Warranty Coverage
New cars often come with full warranty coverage. Most manufacturers offer up to three years or 36,000 miles. This protects you from unexpected repair costs during that time.
Warranties usually cover mechanical issues and manufacturer defects. You can drive without worrying about major repairs. It’s peace of mind—and saves money on maintenance costs early on!
2. Latest Technology and Safety Features
Newer cars offer advanced safety tools. Features like blind-spot warnings, lane-keeping assist, and automatic emergency braking improve protection. Many also include driver-assistance systems for parking or highway driving.
Touchscreens, voice controls, and smartphone pairing enhance the experience. Automakers like Toyota and Lexus focus on updates to meet new emission rules while boosting efficiency.
But watch out—J.D. Power has reported faulty airbags and transmission issues in some models this year.
3. Better Fuel Efficiency and Emission Standards
New cars meet higher emission standards. They use better technology to cut fuel use and pollution. Improved engines lower the carbon footprint, saving money on gas over time.
Hybrids and electric vehicles are great eco-friendly options. These models reduce emissions even more while costing less to run daily. Fuel-efficient choices mean a cleaner environment and long-term savings for you!
4. Customization and Personalization Options
In new cars, you can pick features like heated seats or a premium sound system. Choose paint colors, interior finishes, and even wheel designs to match your style. Some brands, like Acura, offer advanced packages for added comfort.
Safety features can also be added. Driver assistance systems such as blind-spot monitoring or adaptive cruise control give you extra security on the road. Customizing lets you create a car that feels just right for your needs.
5. Lower Maintenance Needs in the Early Years
New cars usually have fewer problems at the start. The parts are new and unlikely to break down. Manufacturers often cover repairs with a full warranty, reducing your risks.
You won’t spend much on maintenance early on. Oil changes and tire checks may be all you need for a while, which saves money compared to used cars that need more frequent fixes or replacement parts.
Drawbacks of Buying a New Car
New cars lose value fast—depreciating when you leave the dealership. They also come with bigger price tags and higher expenses upfront.
1. Higher Purchase Price and Upfront Costs
Buying a new car costs more upfront. In 2021, the average price of a new vehicle was $40,000. By January 2025, that number jumped to $48,641. Models priced over $60,000 increased by 163% during this time.
This means you may need larger loans or higher monthly payments.
The typical loan amount for a new vehicle is about $40,184. Higher purchase prices also mean more significant down payments and sales taxes. Interest rates can increase quickly if financing through banks like Capital One or Bank of America.
Be prepared for these expenses before making your choice.
2. Rapid Depreciation in the First Few Years
New cars lose value quickly. Their value drops 20% in the first year and about 60% by five years. A car that costs $30,000 new might sell for only $12,000 after five years.
This sharp drop can leave you “underwater” on your loan. You may owe more than your car is worth. Depreciation hits hardest early on but slows with time. Buying a slightly used car—like one that’s a year old—saves money since it keeps about 80% of its price but skips the steepest loss.
3. Higher Insurance Premiums
Insurance premiums are higher for new cars. On average, rates for a five-year-old car are 27% lower than those for a brand-new vehicle. Newer models cost more to repair or replace, increasing insurance costs.
Cars priced above $60,000 have also increased significantly—by 163%—making insurance even more expensive.
Insurers see used vehicles as less risky in terms of payouts. Their book value is lower, so claims cost less if the car gets totaled. If your budget matters, choosing a pre-owned plan could save money on your monthly coverage plan while still providing proper protection through auto insurance options.
Benefits of Buying a Used Car
A used car often costs much less than a brand-new model—giving you more options within your budget. Plus, it keeps its value better over time!
1. Lower Purchase Price and Better Value for Money
Used cars save you money upfront. The average price for a used car was $25,128 in January 2025. This is much less than most new cars. You also avoid extra fees like high delivery charges from dealerships.
Monthly payments for used car loans are lower, around $533 on average. Buyers borrow about $27,167 for a used vehicle—much less debt compared to new ones. This makes it easier to stay within your budget and still get good value.
2. Slower Depreciation Rate
A used car loses value at a slower pace. New cars lose 20% of their worth in the first year and about 60% within five years. A one-year-old vehicle keeps more value—around 80% of its original price.
After hitting 100,000 miles, depreciation slows even more.
You’ll get better resale value with an older car over time. These autos hold onto their worth longer than brand-new ones. Buying pre-owned could save you from steep depreciation losses early on.
3. Lower Insurance Costs
Insurance premiums for used cars are often lower. A five-year-old car costs 27% less to insure than a new one, making it easier on your wallet each month.
Cars under $15,000 may cost even less to insure because they often have lower repair costs after accidents. Used cars also help with savings on coverage options that aren’t always necessary for older vehicles.
4. Wider Variety of Models Within Budget
Buying a used car gives you more choices for your money. Cars priced under $25,000 have become harder to find among new models—sales dropped 78% in five years. With used cars, you can explore options like SUVs, trucks, or certified pre-owned vehicles without breaking the bank.
Used vehicles often include features from higher trims that might cost too much on a new car. Discounts on older models help stretch your budget further. Use tools like vehicle history reports and auto loan calculators to ensure you get good value while sticking to your price range.
Drawbacks of Buying a Used Car
Used cars can have unexpected repair bills that add up quickly. Plus, you might not know the vehicle’s complete history, leaving questions about its reliability.
1. Potential for Higher Repairs and Maintenance Costs
Older cars often have higher repair and maintenance costs. As vehicles age, parts wear out or fail, leading to frequent fixes. For instance, brake rotors may need replacing, or the transmission might worsen over time.
You could face costly repairs like these if the car is no longer under warranty.
Newer cars usually include a warranty lasting three years or 36,000 miles. This can help cover major issues—like faulty airbags reported by JD Power in some models. Without coverage, you’ll pay out of pocket for everything from minor repairs to expensive engine work.
Always check the maintenance history before buying to avoid hidden surprises.
2. Limited or No Warranty Coverage
Used cars often come with limited or no warranty coverage. This means you might face repair costs on your own if something breaks. New cars, in contrast, usually include full warranties, giving you peace of mind for several years.
Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) vehicles are a better choice if you want some coverage. These cars pass inspections and offer extended warranties. They cost more but reduce the risk of unexpected repair bills.
Always check the details before buying to avoid surprises later.
3. Uncertainty About Vehicle History
Not all used cars come with detailed past records. Some may have hidden issues like accidents, flood damage, or odometer rollbacks. Without proper checks, you could face costly surprises later.
Always request a vehicle history report from trusted sources like CARFAX or AutoCheck. Have a mechanic inspect the car before buying to avoid risks and ensure safer long-term ownership.
4. Fewer Customization Options
Used cars often lack customization options. You can’t always pick your desired color, features, or upgrades. Unlike new cars, which let you choose from a manufacturer’s suggested retail price list of add-ons, used models come as-is.
Older vehicles may also lack newer tech, such as advanced safety features or blind-spot monitoring. If personalizing your car matters to you, this might feel limiting. Shopping carefully can help you find something closer to your taste without breaking your budget.
Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Cars: A Middle Ground?
CPO cars give you the perks of a new car with the cost savings of a used one—learn why they might be worth it.
What Are CPO Cars?
Certified pre-owned cars are a step between new and used vehicles. They undergo detailed inspections to meet strict standards set by manufacturers or dealers. They often come with warranties, giving you peace of mind about repairs.
You also get perks like roadside assistance or free maintenance for a limited time. CPO cars usually cost more than regular used cars because of the extra care and protection. It’s a way to buy pre-owned with added confidence.
Advantages of CPO Cars Over Regular Used Cars
CPO cars come with a warranty, offering peace of mind. Regularly used cars often lack this coverage, leaving you to handle unexpected repair costs. You also get an inspection report showing the car’s condition.
This means fewer surprises compared to buying a non-certified vehicle.
While CPO vehicles cost more upfront, they save money on maintenance and repairs later. Many include benefits like roadside assistance or free maintenance for a limited time. These extras make them safer if you’re worried about reliability or hidden issues in used cars.
Are They Worth the Extra Cost?
CPO cars cost more than regular used ones. This is because they include warranties and inspections. You pay for peace of mind knowing experts checked the vehicle.
This option makes sense if you want reliability without buying a new car. While the upfront price is higher, you save on surprise repair costs later. They may also have better trade-in value compared to non-certified used cars.
Making the Right Decision: Which Option Suits You Best?
Think about how much you can spend—upfront and monthly. Compare repair costs, loan terms, and resale value for each choice.
Assess Your Financial Situation
Check how much money you have saved. Use tools like the EveryDollar app to track your budget and savings goals. Paying in cash is always best, so aim for that if possible.
Think about monthly costs too. Auto loans mean interest payments, which add up over time. Compare financing options carefully. A higher credit score can get you a lower rate on loans or refinancing deals.
Planning well now saves stress later!
Determine Your Long-Term Needs
Think about how long you plan to keep the car. Buying a new one might be better if you have wanted a vehicle for many years. New cars have full warranty coverage and fewer maintenance issues upfront.
This can save money over time.
Leasing could work if you only need it short-term or prefer frequent upgrades. Leasing offers lower monthly payments and lets you switch cars often. Research incentives like cashback deals or low financing rates before deciding.
Evaluate Ownership Costs Beyond the Purchase Price
Owning a car costs more than just the sticker price. You’ll face ongoing expenses like gas, maintenance, and repairs. Used cars may need frequent fixes, while new vehicles could have lower repair needs but higher insurance premiums.
Insurance companies might charge more for newer models due to their value. Older cars usually cost less to insure but might require extended warranty coverage or out-of-pocket payments for unexpected breakdowns.
Remember that other fees, such as registration, taxes, and financing interest rates, can increase over time. Consider these before deciding!
Research Vehicle Reliability and Resale Value
Check the car’s reliability before buying. Use resources like Kelley Blue Book and Edmunds for accurate information. Reliable vehicles cost less to maintain and last longer. Toyota, Honda, and Subaru are often praised for their dependability.
Look at resale value, too. Cars with high depreciation lose money fast when sold later, while a used car with slower depreciation can save you more in the long run. Compare models on TrueCar or market reports for trends.
This research helps protect your investment.
Check Financing and Interest Rates for Both Options
Compare loan rates before making a decision. Preapproval can help you secure better deals. PenFed Auto Loans offer APRs starting at 4.44%. Loan terms range from 36 to 84 months, with no early payoff fees.
Interest rates may vary for new and used cars. Due to smaller loan amounts, used car loans often have higher rates but lower total costs. Check your credit score—it impacts the rate you qualify for.
The Bottom Line
Buying a new or used car depends on your needs and budget. New cars offer perks like warranties and the latest tech but have higher costs.
Used cars save money upfront and depreciate slower, but might need more care.
Before deciding, consider insurance, loans, and long-term expenses. Take your time to find what best suits you!
